Tricyclic Antidepressants Test Evidence
Has Caused a False Positive
Cyclobenzaprine
3 sources Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007 Poklis et al., J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 1997 Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009
What It Found
- The muscle relaxant reacted with urine TCA screening in emergency department patients and in spiked urine.
Source Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007
What It Found
- One comparison found false positives more often with Biosite than with Syva.
Tests Studied
- Biosite Triage
- Syva Rapid Test
Source Lin et al., J Anal Toxicol 2013
What It Found
- Cyclobenzaprine alone at 1,000 ng/mL produced a positive result on the NexScreen cup despite a higher manufacturer-listed concentration.
Keep in Mind
- This spike experiment is separate from the multi-drug patient pools.
Test Studied
- NexScreen urine cup TCA strip
3 sources Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007 Poklis et al., J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 1997 Lin et al., J Anal Toxicol 2013
Keep in Mind
- Which device was used matters.
2 sources Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007 Poklis et al., J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 1997
Keep in Mind
- Neither a positive screen nor its apparent strength can establish TCA toxicity.
Prochlorperazine
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- The case-level supplementary table identifies prochlorperazine by GC-MS and lists it as the probable explanation for a Biosite Triage urine TCA result.
Keep in Mind
- This is a patient-level attribution on an older test.
- Reagent and concentration matter.
Test Studied
- Biosite Triage urine TCA screen
Alimemazine
Source FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019
What It Found
- In manufacturer testing submitted to FDA, adding trimeprazine to urine produced a TCA-positive result at 83.5 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- This was an analytical challenge at a specified concentration.
- The report does not establish a typical false-positive rate in people taking the medicine.
Test Studied
- Quidel Triage TOX urine TCA assay, K182719
Chlorprothixene
Source FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019
What It Found
- In manufacturer testing submitted to FDA, adding chlorprothixene to urine produced a TCA-positive result at 40 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- This was an analytical challenge at a specified concentration.
- The report does not establish a typical false-positive rate in people taking the medicine.
Test Studied
- Quidel Triage TOX urine TCA assay, K182719
Also cited: Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Corticosterone
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- The 2009 comparison lists reactivity at 75,000 ng/mL for Corticosterone on the Biosite Triage screen.
Keep in Mind
- This laboratory comparison used historical reagents.
- It gives no frequency after routine use.
- The result depends on the reagent, the cutoff and the concentration in the specimen.
Tests Studied
- Biosite Triage Tricyclic antidepressants (TCA) screen, Krasowski et al. supplement, R
- TRICYCLICS, row 61
Deoxycorticosterone
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- The 2009 comparison lists reactivity at 75,000 ng/mL for Deoxycorticosterone on the Biosite Triage screen.
Keep in Mind
- This laboratory comparison used historical reagents.
- It gives no frequency after routine use.
- The result depends on the reagent, the cutoff and the concentration in the specimen.
Tests Studied
- Biosite Triage Tricyclic antidepressants (TCA) screen, Krasowski et al. supplement, R
- TRICYCLICS, row 62
Maprotiline
Source FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019
What It Found
- In manufacturer testing submitted to FDA, adding maprotiline to urine produced a TCA-positive result at 240 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- This was an analytical challenge at a specified concentration.
- The report does not establish a typical false-positive rate in people taking the medicine.
Test Studied
- Quidel Triage TOX urine TCA assay, K182719
Also cited: Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Perphenazine
Source FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019
What It Found
- In manufacturer testing submitted to FDA, adding perphenazine to urine produced a TCA-positive result at 175 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- This was an analytical challenge at a specified concentration.
- The report does not establish a typical false-positive rate in people taking the medicine.
Test Studied
- Quidel Triage TOX urine TCA assay, K182719
Also cited: Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Phenothiazine
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- The 2009 comparison lists reactivity at 60,000 ng/mL for Phenothiazine on the Biosite Triage screen.
- The tested substance was the parent chemical.
- Individual phenothiazine medicines have their own results.
Keep in Mind
- This laboratory comparison used historical reagents.
- It gives no frequency after routine use.
- The result depends on the reagent, the cutoff and the concentration in the specimen.
Tests Studied
- Biosite Triage Tricyclic antidepressants (TCA) screen, Krasowski et al. supplement, R
- TRICYCLICS, row 59
Promazine
Source FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019
What It Found
- In manufacturer testing submitted to FDA, adding promazine to urine produced a TCA-positive result at 35 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- This was an analytical challenge at a specified concentration.
- The report does not establish a typical false-positive rate in people taking the medicine.
Test Studied
- Quidel Triage TOX urine TCA assay, K182719
Also cited: Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Rimcazole
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- The 2009 comparison lists reactivity at 50,000 ng/mL for Rimcazole on the Biosite Triage screen.
Keep in Mind
- This laboratory comparison used historical reagents.
- It gives no frequency after routine use.
- The result depends on the reagent, the cutoff and the concentration in the specimen.
Tests Studied
- Biosite Triage Tricyclic antidepressants (TCA) screen, Krasowski et al. supplement, R
- TRICYCLICS, row 50
Clozapine
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists clozapine as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 100 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Lisuride
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists lisuride as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 7.5 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Nefazodone
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists nefazodone as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 100 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Perazine
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists perazine as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 10 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Prednisone
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists prednisone as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 50 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Progesterone
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists progesterone as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 75 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Thiothixene
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists thiothixene as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 20 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Zaleplon
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A 2009 compilation of assay specifications lists zaleplon as reactive on the Biosite Triage urine test at 65 micrograms/mL.
Keep in Mind
- The tabulated laboratory value does not establish that a prescribed dose produces this result.
- Verify the instructions for the particular reagent currently in use.
Source Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA test, supplementary table R
Depends on the Brand of Test
Carbamazepine
Source Saidinejad et al., Pediatrics 2007
What It Found
- The pediatric study found interference in serum, with none on its urine assay.
Tests Studied
- Urine enzyme-linked TCA screen in a pediatric study
- Serum fluorescence polarization was evaluated separately
Source MEDTOX Diagnostics. PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan Drugs of Abuse Test System, FDA 510(k) summary…, 2009
What It Found
- On PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan, carbamazepine and its 10,11-epoxide were each negative at 100,000 ng/mL.
Source FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022
What It Found
- On DRI, neither 5,000 ng/mL of carbamazepine nor 30,000 ng/mL of the epoxide changed the urine controls.
2 sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A historical Biosite Triage table lists no response to the parent drug, but its iminostilbene metabolite reached the equivalent cutoff at 75,000 ng/mL.
Keep in Mind
- An emergency department series listed carbamazepine as the probable explanation in a Triage urine case.
2 sources Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2022 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2021
Keep in Mind
- Postmortem studies found it in some specimens with unconfirmed results.
3 sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2022 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2021
Keep in Mind
- Those observations cannot identify the interfering compound.
2 sources Saidinejad et al., Pediatrics 2007 FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022
Keep in Mind
- The serum studies do not establish the likelihood of a urine false positive after treatment.
4 sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2022 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2021
Test Studied
- Biosite Triage and postmortem urine devices
2 sources FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022 MEDTOX Diagnostics. PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan Drugs of Abuse Test System, FDA 510(k) summary…, 2009
Test Studied
- PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan and Microgenics DRI urine TCA assays
Chlorpromazine
Source FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022
What It Found
- Chlorpromazine at 600 ng/mL reached the DRI cutoff.
Source MEDTOX Diagnostics. PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan Drugs of Abuse Test System, FDA 510(k) summary…, 2009
What It Found
- On PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan it remained negative even at 100,000 ng/mL.
2 sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A historical Biosite Triage table lists a cutoff-equivalent response at 50,000 ng/mL.
Test Studied
- Historical Biosite Triage urine TCA assay
4 sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2022 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2021
What It Found
- Investigators also identified chlorpromazine in a hospital specimen and in postmortem specimens with unconfirmed TCA results.
Keep in Mind
- Detection of chlorpromazine in a particular specimen establishes exposure but cannot by itself identify the cause of its screening result.
4 sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009 FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022 MEDTOX Diagnostics. PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan Drugs of Abuse Test System, FDA 510(k) summary…, 2009
Keep in Mind
- The results depend on which test was used.
2 sources FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022 MEDTOX Diagnostics. PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan Drugs of Abuse Test System, FDA 510(k) summary…, 2009
Test Studied
- Microgenics DRI urine TCA assay and PROFILE-V MEDTOXScan urine TCA channel, each with a 300 ng/mL cutoff
2 sources Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2022 Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2021
Test Studied
- Postmortem urine screening studies
Diphenhydramine
Source Ito et al., BMC Neurol 2026
What It Found
- Two adolescent overdose cases produced TCA-positive screens.
- In a urine spiking experiment, the screen changed from negative at 100 micrograms/mL diphenhydramine to positive at 500.
2 sources Ito et al., BMC Neurol 2026 Nishimura et al., J Anal Toxicol 2026
What It Found
- The patients’ urine contained less parent drug, so metabolites may have contributed.
Test Studied
- Abbott SIGNIFY ER urine TCA screen
Source Lin et al., J Anal Toxicol 2013
What It Found
- The authors reported no cup interference with Diphenhydramine added at 1,000 ng/mL in drug-free urine.
Keep in Mind
- The DrugCheck comparison cup did not include a TCA panel.
- Other devices or concentrations can differ.
Test Studied
- NexScreen urine cup, TCA strip
4 sources Ito et al., BMC Neurol 2026 Nishimura et al., J Anal Toxicol 2026 Kim et al., Asian Biomed (Res Rev News) 2023 Yokoyama et al., Cureus 2024
Keep in Mind
- The evidence primarily concerns overdose.
- It does not establish that an ordinary allergy dose will produce a positive TCA screen.
3 sources Nishimura et al., J Anal Toxicol 2026 Kim et al., Asian Biomed (Res Rev News) 2023 Yokoyama et al., Cureus 2024
Test Studied
- Additional case reports
Quetiapine
Source Hendrickson and Morocco, J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 2003
What It Found
- Urine from a patient taking prescribed quetiapine and from an overdose patient tested positive with Syva and Microgenics.
- Both specimens were negative on Biosite Triage, which also remained negative in the laboratory challenge.
Keep in Mind
- These results apply to the specific reagents and conditions tested.
- The Microgenics serum-tox assay was used experimentally on urine.
Test Studied
- Syva RapidTest d.a.u., Microgenics TCA EIA tested in urine and Biosite Triage
Source Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2022
What It Found
- The authors found Quetiapine among medicines present in specimens with unconfirmed TCA results across the three devices.
Keep in Mind
- This was a postmortem series.
- It did not isolate each medicine as the cause of every positive channel.
Test Studied
- Triage DOA, Status DS10, and DRIVEN-FLOW M8-Z, compared with GC-MS/LC-MS/MS in postmortem urine
Source Tanaka et al., Leg Med (Tokyo) 2021
What It Found
- Quetiapine was among medications identified across the TCA-negative-by-mass-spectrometry cases with positive screening results in a 340-autopsy series.
Keep in Mind
- The abstract pools the two devices and several compounds.
- It does not establish which particular drug caused each result or predict outcomes after routine treatment.
Test Studied
- Triage DOA and DRIVEN-FLOW M7-II in postmortem urine
Also cited: Chathanchirayil, Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2011; Sloan et al., Am J Psychiatry 2000
Cyproheptadine
Source Randox Laboratories. Evidence MultiSTAT DOA Urine Array EV4193. Tricyclic antidepressant…
What It Found
- Cyproheptadine reacted on the Randox urine TCA assay at about 230 ng/mL.
Test Studied
- Randox Evidence MultiSTAT DOA Urine Array (150 ng/mL nortriptyline cutoff)
Source FDA 510(k) K253567. Healgen Accurate Urine Drug Screen Dip Card and Home Urine Drug Test…, 2025
What It Found
- On the Healgen dip card, adding 100 µg/mL of cyproheptadine did not change the TCA result.
Test Studied
- Healgen Accurate urine dip card (1,000 ng/mL nortriptyline cutoff)
Both sources Randox Laboratories. Evidence MultiSTAT DOA Urine Array EV4193. Tricyclic antidepressant… FDA 510(k) K253567. Healgen Accurate Urine Drug Screen Dip Card and Home Urine Drug Test…, 2025
Keep in Mind
- These experiments identify marked differences between urine assays.
- They do not estimate how often a prescribed dose affects a patient’s urine test.
The Test Is Made to Find It
Clomipramine
Source Poklis et al., J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 1997
What It Found
- Clomipramine belongs to the target class and produced a reaction in spiked urine on Triage Plus.
Test Studied
- Triage Plus TCA urine screens
Source Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007
What It Found
- However, a clinical comparison found that two point-of-care urine assays did not detect every patient with elevated serum concentrations.
Test Studied
- Syva Rapid Test, Biosite Triage
2 sources Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007 Meenan et al., J Anal Toxicol 1990
What It Found
- Both assays detected clomipramine at 1,000 ng/mL.
- The Syva system missed it at 400 ng/mL.
Keep in Mind
- A negative urine result cannot exclude clomipramine exposure or toxicity.
Source Meenan et al., J Anal Toxicol 1990
Keep in Mind
- This describes expected recognition of a tricyclic antidepressant with these two historical urine methods.
Test Studied
- Abbott ADx urine FPIA and Syva ETS adapted serum Emittox TCA reagents for urine
Amitriptyline
Source Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007
What It Found
- Amitriptyline is itself a tricyclic antidepressant.
- The two urine assays detected patients across a range of serum concentrations in the comparative study.
Keep in Mind
- A urine result alone cannot determine the dose, the blood concentration or the severity of an overdose.
Test Studied
- Syva Rapid Test and Biosite Triage urine TCA screens
Desipramine
Source Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007
What It Found
- Desipramine is itself a tricyclic antidepressant.
- The two urine assays detected patients across a range of serum concentrations in the comparative study.
Keep in Mind
- A urine result alone cannot determine the dose, the blood concentration or the severity of an overdose.
Test Studied
- Syva Rapid Test and Biosite Triage urine TCA screens
Doxepin
Source Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007
What It Found
- Doxepin is itself a tricyclic antidepressant.
- The two urine assays detected patients across a range of serum concentrations in the comparative study.
Keep in Mind
- A urine result alone cannot determine the dose, the blood concentration or the severity of an overdose.
Test Studied
- Syva Rapid Test and Biosite Triage urine TCA screens
Imipramine
Source Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007
What It Found
- Imipramine is itself a tricyclic antidepressant.
- The two urine assays detected patients across a range of serum concentrations in the comparative study.
Keep in Mind
- A urine result alone cannot determine the dose, the blood concentration or the severity of an overdose.
Test Studied
- Syva Rapid Test and Biosite Triage urine TCA screens
Nortriptyline
Source Melanson et al., J Anal Toxicol 2007
What It Found
- Nortriptyline is itself a tricyclic antidepressant.
- The two urine assays detected patients across a range of serum concentrations in the comparative study.
Keep in Mind
- A urine result alone cannot determine the dose, the blood concentration or the severity of an overdose.
Test Studied
- Syva Rapid Test and Biosite Triage urine TCA screens
Protriptyline
Source Poklis et al., J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 1997
What It Found
- Protriptyline, a tricyclic antidepressant, produced a positive result in urine spiked at the study cutoff.
Keep in Mind
- Spiked urine demonstrates that the assay can recognize the drug.
- Detection in a person also depends on concentration.
Test Studied
- Triage Plus TCA urine screen
Suspected, but Not Proven
Hydroxyzine
2 sources Hughey and Colby, Clin Chem 2019 Hughey and Colby. Central laboratory urine drug screening study, version 1 data and…, 2019
What It Found
- In hospital records, people with a documented hydroxyzine exposure had about twice the odds of an unconfirmed Abbott urine TCA result.
Keep in Mind
- The hospital association cannot establish that hydroxyzine caused a urine positive.
Source FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022
What It Found
- On DRI, adding 5,000 ng/mL of hydroxyzine to urine preserved both the negative and positive control results.
Source American Bio Medica Corporation. Rapid TOX urine drug screen product instructions…, 2009
What It Found
- Rapid TOX lists hydroxyzine among compounds its urine panel did not detect below 100,000 ng/mL.
Test Studied
- Rapid TOX urine TCA strip (1,000 ng/mL cutoff)
Source Randox Toxicology. ELISA Solutions, tricyclic antidepressant assay specificity and…, 2016
Keep in Mind
- Randox reports less than 0.1% relative response in a shared specificity table for its blood and urine protocols, without a urine-only positive threshold.
Test Studied
- A Randox ELISA specificity table
2 sources Dasgupta et al., Ther Drug Monit 2007 HelloPharmacist. Can Hydroxyzine Cause A False Positive For A Benzo?, 2022
Keep in Mind
- Hydroxyzine and its metabolite cetirizine produced apparent TCA results in a separate serum experiment.
3 sources Hughey and Colby, Clin Chem 2019 Hughey and Colby. Central laboratory urine drug screening study, version 1 data and…, 2019 FDA decision summary K213875. Microgenics DRI Tricyclics Serum Tox Assay, urine…, 2022
Test Studied
- Abbott MULTIGENT and Microgenics DRI urine TCA tests (300 ng/mL cutoff)
Source Dasgupta et al., Ther Drug Monit 2007
Test Studied
- A separate fluorescence polarization experiment used blood serum
Topiramate
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- A discordant Triage urine contained a high apparent concentration of topiramate.
Keep in Mind
- The supplementary case table listed the drug as present and left the probable-cause field empty.
- This observation does not establish cross-reactivity.
Test Studied
- Biosite Triage urine TCA screen
Venlafaxine
Both sources Krasowski et al., BMC Emerg Med 2009 Krasowski et al. Additional file 1. Historical assay cross-reactivity tables and reagent…, 2009
What It Found
- Several discordant Triage urines contained high apparent concentrations of venlafaxine and desvenlafaxine.
Keep in Mind
- The supplementary case table listed the drug as present and left the probable-cause field empty.
- This observation does not establish cross-reactivity.
Test Studied
- Biosite Triage urine TCA screen
Levomepromazine
Source Gomółka et al., Przegl Lek 2012
What It Found
- A patient who reported taking levomepromazine (Tisercin) and a stimulant supplement had a positive TCA screen.
- The investigators detected phenothiazines by chromatography and suggested that this drug class explained the result.
Keep in Mind
- There were multiple exposures.
- The report did not isolate levomepromazine or its metabolites as the cause and did not test the individual drug on the assay.
Test Studied
- Urine immunoassay and follow-up HPLC with diode-array detection in a Polish poisoning case
Tested: No False Positive Found
Benzocaine
3 sources One-Step Tricyclic Antidepressants MonlabTest urine cassette. Instructions for use…, 2023 FDA 510(k) K142396. Chemtrue BUP/TCA drug screen dip card, cup and cassette tests, 2014 FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019
What It Found
- Benzocaine at 100 µg/mL did not cause a false positive on three urine TCA devices tested in the laboratory.
2 sources Hughey and Colby, Clin Chem 2019 Hughey and Colby. Central laboratory urine drug screening study, version 1 data and…, 2019
What It Found
- Hospital records showed no clear link between benzocaine exposure and an unconfirmed TCA result.
Test Studied
- A hospital study used Abbott MULTIGENT
4 sources One-Step Tricyclic Antidepressants MonlabTest urine cassette. Instructions for use…, 2023 FDA 510(k) K142396. Chemtrue BUP/TCA drug screen dip card, cup and cassette tests, 2014 FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019 American Bio Medica Corporation. Rapid TOX urine drug screen product instructions…, 2009
Keep in Mind
- The manufacturers tested benzocaine added to urine.
All 6 sources One-Step Tricyclic Antidepressants MonlabTest urine cassette. Instructions for use…, 2023 FDA 510(k) K142396. Chemtrue BUP/TCA drug screen dip card, cup and cassette tests, 2014 Hughey and Colby, Clin Chem 2019 Hughey and Colby. Central laboratory urine drug screening study, version 1 data and…, 2019 FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019 American Bio Medica Corporation. Rapid TOX urine drug screen product instructions…, 2009
Keep in Mind
- These studies cannot predict the result on every device or tell us how often someone would test positive after using a benzocaine product.
2 sources One-Step Tricyclic Antidepressants MonlabTest urine cassette. Instructions for use…, 2023 FDA 510(k) K142396. Chemtrue BUP/TCA drug screen dip card, cup and cassette tests, 2014
Test Studied
- MonlabTest and Chemtrue urine TCA tests (1,000 ng/mL nortriptyline cutoff)
Source FDA 510(k) decision summary for Quidel Triage TOX Drug Screen, K182719. Analytical…, 2019
Test Studied
- The Quidel Triage TOX urine TCA channel (1,000 ng/mL desipramine cutoff)
Oxcarbazepine
Source Saidinejad et al., Pediatrics 2007
What It Found
- In a pediatric study, children taking oxcarbazepine showed no significant TCA activity on the urine assay.
Keep in Mind
- The tested method and treated population do not establish a guarantee across all platforms.
Test Studied
- Urine enzyme-linked TCA assay
Acetaminophen
Source Lin et al., J Anal Toxicol 2013
What It Found
- The authors reported no cup interference with Acetaminophen added at 1,000 ng/mL in drug-free urine.
Keep in Mind
- The DrugCheck comparison cup did not include a TCA panel.
- Other devices or concentrations can differ.
Test Studied
- NexScreen urine cup, TCA strip
Dextromethorphan
Source Lin et al., J Anal Toxicol 2013
What It Found
- The authors reported no cup interference with Dextromethorphan added at 1,000 ng/mL in drug-free urine.
Keep in Mind
- The DrugCheck comparison cup did not include a TCA panel.
- Other devices or concentrations can differ.
Test Studied
- NexScreen urine cup, TCA strip
Meprobamate
Source Lin et al., J Anal Toxicol 2013
What It Found
- The authors reported no cup interference with Meprobamate added at 1,000 ng/mL in drug-free urine.
Keep in Mind
- The DrugCheck comparison cup did not include a TCA panel.
- Other devices or concentrations can differ.
Test Studied
- NexScreen urine cup, TCA strip